There Is A War Going On For Your Mind
Belief
You did not form your beliefs. You were handed them.
By your family, your community, your culture, your country, your God, your feed, your school, your pain, your fear. Every force that has ever surrounded you has had an opinion about who you should be and what you should think. Most of them have expected that you remain inside the lines.
This, admittedly, sounds like a conspiracy. But, rationally, it is simply how the world works. Every system, every community, and every institution has an interest in your agreement. Not necessarily because they are malicious, (though some are) but because shared belief is the foundation of collective identity, and collective identity is how any group sustains itself. The tribe needs you to think like the tribe. The faith needs you to believe like the faithful. The party needs you to vote for what it wants. And they will offer you genuine things, like community, meaning, purpose, love, and certainty, in exchange for your unwavering compliance. It is in their best interest to do so.
No matter what, you will never fully escape this. That is worth saying bluntly, because a lot of philosophy on this subject pretends otherwise. It suggests that if you read the right books, think the right thoughts, and commit yourself to reason, (usually the philosopher’s reasoning) you can achieve something similar to intellectual independence. But you cannot, at least not entirely. You are still a social animal. You are malleable. The people, systems, and algorithms around you shape your perception, vocabulary, values, and desires in ways you will never fully see or account for. This is because of biology: total independence and/or awareness is a fantasy. And any so-called free thinker has simply failed to identify all the forces that made them who they are.
The question is never whether you are being influenced. You are. The question is whether you are aware of it, and by how much.
Thought
The world is full of forces that would prefer you not to think too carefully. Not necessarily because thinking is dangerous to truth, but because thinking is dangerous to systems that depend on your unexamined loyalty. Tribalism requires that you see the other side as a threat rather than a different perspective. Outrage requires that you react before you reflect. Dogma requires that you accept before you question. The manufactured certainty that these systems offer is a leash pretending to be a compass. It restricts your worldview to a cherrypicked fairytale, preventing you from seeing the bigger picture.
Yet even if you think deeply about everything, you will still be wrong sometimes. Thinking carefully does not guarantee correct conclusions. Freedom from one ideology does not mean freedom from all bias. The person who leaves a religion can become just as rigid in their secularism. The person who leaves a political tribe can become just as certain in their independence. The error is not in having beliefs, you always will, but in mistaking them for conclusions rather than hypotheses. In treating your current understanding as the objective truth rather than a position.
Relations
This is why the most important question is often not what you believe, but how you hold it.
Do you hold your beliefs with enough honesty to examine them? With enough humility to revise them? With enough self awareness to ask who influenced them, and why? With enough openness to consider that you might be wrong? With enough discipline to seek out what challenges them, not just what confirms them? With enough courage to remain yourself even when the people you love look at your independent thinking and call it sin, or stupidity, or betrayal?
Because they will, which is perhaps the most disorienting part of this. The pressure to conform does not always come from strangers. It comes from your family, your closest friends, and the communities that shaped you before you had any say in the matter. And when you begin to think differently, the response is often not curiosity or acceptance. It is fear. And fear, in people who love you, expresses itself as judgment.
I have experienced this myself. I was indoctrinated as a child into many different factions and was fully convinced with unwavering commitment in what I believed must be true. Yet, I was an intensely rational boy, and I honestly still am. Eventually, I started thinking for myself, questioning the principles I had held deeply for years, and after a significant period of inner conflict, research, and experimentation, I ultimately came to the conclusion that these principles were incomplete and/or misguided. And the reaction I got from family, friends, and community who still believed in them was… not fun. To this day, I am still threatened by these people simply because I do not share their beliefs. I am treated as subhuman because I acknowledge the humanity of the situation.
It’s sad, because they were indoctrinated too. They defend their worldview fiercely because they were forced to. And just as I was unwavering in my commitment despite all counterarguments, they too are now. This is not an excuse to hate those who’ve wronged you, because they often didn’t choose to either. Hate is not a solution and is certainly not an excuse to feel superior to those still inside constricting systems. The person who escapes a system and becomes smug about it has simply traded one form of blindness for another. You are not inherently better than the people you left behind, you are just in a different place. None of this matters if you simply become part of the problem you escaped.
The only answer to this is to become, as much as possible, your own judge. Not in the sense of arrogance or isolation, but in the sense that you are the one who ultimately has to live inside your own mind and who has to live your own life. You are the one who has to look at your beliefs and decide if they are yours and if they are worth it. No community can do that for you. No institution can do that for you. No system, however warm, however certain, however loving, can stand between you and the responsibility of thinking for yourself. And similarly, respect that others are their own judges. There is no mutual benefit or virtue in forcing your beliefs onto another.
Freedom
If you are thinking, you are winning. Not because thinking guarantees you being right, but because thinking keeps you engaged. It keeps you from being fully manipulated. It keeps the conversation between you and your own mind open, which is the only conversation that ultimately cannot be fabricated by someone else.
This war is not one that will end. The forces that want your unthinking loyalty are not going anywhere. In fact, they will evolve. They will find new forms. They will offer new rewards and new threats. And you will, throughout your life, be partially shaped by them, because that is the condition of being human in a world made by and of other humans. But there is a difference between being influenced and being owned. Between a worldview that was handed to you and one that you have held up to the light, questioned, revised, and chosen to keep, or chosen to leave behind.
Even the entire Codex is subject to this. It is not neutral, even if it tries or claims to be. It is full of opinions, held by one person, shaped by one life, filtered through one mind that has been wrong before and will be wrong again. Take it as such. Push back. Think. Decide what is better for you and what is not. There is no substitute for individuality.
I am not a hero. I’m just an angry man who wants us all to do better.
Be your own person. Come to your own conclusions. Question everything. And do not mistake this for an invitation to join the tribe of people who pride themselves on belonging to no tribe. ‘Free thinker’ can become its own identity, its own dogma, its own source of unearned certainty. The goal is to actually practice independence, quietly, imperfectly, and without needing anyone to notice. This is not an easy way to live. But if you’re the kind of person who prefers clarity over comfort, it might be better.
Loading comments…